Variety’s ranking of the 100 Greatest Movie Stars of All Time has sparked debate among film fans, with criticism directed at its placements, inclusions and omissions since its publication on November 18.
Marilyn Monroe takes the top spot, followed by Humphrey Bogart and Charlie Chaplin. Jack Nicholson ranks fourth as the highest-placed living star, while Katharine Hepburn and Sidney Poitier complete the top six. Tom Cruise comes in eighth.
Some of the lower placements have also drawn attention. Denzel Washington ranks 20th, while Eddie Murphy appears at 96, below younger stars including Timothée Chalamet, who ranks 86th, and Zendaya at 98th. Sylvester Stallone is placed 99th.
Chance the Rapper was among those reported to have questioned the list's preference for older Hollywood stars, asking on social media whether the ranking had been compiled in 1956.
The omissions have generated further criticism. Jackie Chan, Johnny Depp, Gene Hackman, Michelle Pfeiffer, Julie Christie, Bruce Willis and Mel Gibson are among the established actors who did not make the 100-person selection. Other names absent include Jim Carrey, Samuel L. Jackson, Keanu Reeves and Cate Blanchett.
Variety said the ranking was compiled by five of its critics: Owen Gleiberman, Guy Lodge, Daniel D’Addario, Alison Herman and Aramide Tinubu. The publication described its approach as a consideration of screen presence, artistry, popularity and wider cultural impact, acknowledging that being a great actor does not automatically make someone a great movie star.
The ranking has reignited a familiar debate about how film stardom should be measured, particularly when comparing performers from different generations. While some readers have questioned the prominence of Golden Age Hollywood figures, others have challenged the exclusion of internationally recognised stars and the placement of contemporary actors.


